Fishing Season Isn't Over Just Because It's Cold

Angler holding a smallmouth bass caught during a cold-weather fishing trip

There have been plenty of winter mornings when I've looked at the temperature and wondered whether going fishing was really a good idea.

Sometimes it wasn't.

I've spent days sitting in a boat freezing because I was dying to get outside, only to wonder a few hours later why I didn't stay home where the heat worked.

But every once in a while, you get one of those days that reminds you exactly why you went.

One of mine happened in the middle of January at Heath Lake in northwest Georgia.

It started out in the 20s that morning, but the forecast called for temperatures to warm fairly quickly. I was fishing from a kayak and targeting crappie with 4-pound test and a small Bobby Garland jig.

I was dragging that little jig across the bottom about as slowly as I could reel it.

And it was working.

I was catching plenty of crappie, but the bites were incredibly subtle. Most of them were little more than a tiny tick in the line. If you weren't paying attention, it would have been easy to miss them completely.

Then I felt another tick.

I set the hook expecting another crappie.

Immediately, I knew something was different.

Either this wasn't a crappie...

or I was about to break some records.

Five Minutes on 4-Pound Test

Whatever I'd hooked wasn't interested in coming to the kayak.

With 4-pound test, there wasn't much I could do about it.

Trying to muscle the fish in would probably end the fight pretty quickly—and not in my favor.

So I took my time.

For roughly five minutes, it became a game of maintaining just enough tension to keep the fish hooked while slowly allowing it to wear itself out.

Eventually, I got it to the surface.

It was an 8-pound largemouth bass.

I'd gone out there to catch crappie.

Instead, one of my most memorable winter fish ate a tiny crappie jig being dragged painfully slowly along the bottom.

That fish reinforced something I've learned over years of winter fishing.

Fishing season isn't over because it's cold.

But you may need to change the way you fish.

Winter Usually Means Slowing Things Down

I fish for several species during the winter, including largemouth and smallmouth bass, crappie and walleye.

I don't approach all of them exactly the same way, and different lakes can behave very differently.

But there are a few things I tend to do as the water gets colder.

I generally start looking toward deeper water.

I slow down.

And quite often, I downsize my presentation.

Cold-water fish can still eat. They're just not necessarily going to behave like fish chasing bait all over the lake during warmer conditions.

Sometimes the strike zone seems incredibly small.

That's when keeping something in front of a fish longer can make the difference.

A shaky head is one of my favorite presentations for exactly that reason. I can fish it slowly and keep it in the strike zone.

I'll also use a wacky rig, crankbait or jerkbait depending on the conditions.

With a jerkbait in cold water, those pauses can get almost ridiculous.

Cast.

Work the bait.

Pause.

Wait.

Wait some more.

Start wondering if you should move it.

Wait a little longer.

Those uncomfortable pauses can be exactly what it takes.

Downsizing Works—Until It Doesn't

Sometimes in winter it seems like you can't downsize enough.

An 8-pound largemouth eating my tiny crappie jig is pretty convincing evidence that a big fish isn't necessarily looking for a big meal.

But I wouldn't turn that into a rule that says you should always throw the smallest lure in your tackle box.

Winter fishing is full of general rules that work right up until the fish decide they don't.

There are times when larger presentations still produce, particularly when bass are feeding on larger forage. Experienced tournament anglers likewise use both finesse presentations and larger jerkbaits under cold-water conditions.

So my approach is pretty simple:

Downsize when the conditions call for it, but pay attention to what the fish are telling you.

Deep Doesn't Always Mean the Same Thing

Another mistake would be saying that all fish simply go deep during winter.

They don't.

Different fisheries behave differently.

I've found big winter smallmouth relating to rock piles on some lakes. On others, finding schools of bait can be more important.

Sometimes we're fishing deep.

Sometimes we're watching for bait balls.

And occasionally we'll see surface activity that makes us completely change what we're doing.

One lake in particular has taught me not to assume that what works everywhere else will automatically work there.

Heath Lake Has Its Own Rules

Heath Lake is part of Rocky Mountain Public Fishing Area near Rome, Georgia. Georgia DNR lists it at 202 acres and manages it for species including largemouth bass and black crappie.

It's an interesting place to fish.

Over years of fishing there, I've learned that during winter I can find crappie relating to the smooth, almost featureless bottom in some of the deepest portions of the lake, around 15 feet.

That's not something I'm suggesting will happen on every lake.

In fact, Georgia DNR's general guidance for Rocky Mountain PFA also identifies flooded timber, rock piles and riprap as productive crappie habitat.

That's exactly the point.

Learning a particular fishery matters.

I've spent enough time on Heath to develop confidence in a winter pattern that works for me there.

Some days we'll essentially crappie and bass fish at the same time.

We may be working slowly for crappie, but if we find bait or suddenly see surface activity, we're ready to change presentations and take advantage of what the lake is showing us.

Don't become so committed to the fishing you planned to do that you ignore the fishing happening right in front of you.

Winter Fishing Requires a Different Clothing System Too

The fish aren't the only thing you have to figure out.

You have to manage yourself.

I've built my cold-weather fishing clothing system much like my hunting system.

Layers matter.

I want moisture management next to my body, insulation to retain heat and an outer layer capable of protecting me from wind and weather.

Wind is a big one for me.

A temperature that seems manageable standing in the driveway can feel completely different after you've been sitting exposed in a boat with cold wind blowing across the water for several hours.

That's why I'm watching more than the number on the thermometer before deciding whether to go.

I look at wind.

Rain.

Snow.

And what the temperature is expected to do throughout the day.

If it's going to stay down in the 20s, I'm generally not interested.

If it starts cold but is expected to warm into a decent day, that's different.

I've gone fishing plenty of times when I probably shouldn't have simply because I wanted to get outside.

Some were worth it.

Some were basically an extended experiment in how long I was willing to be cold.

Cold Water Changes the Consequences

There's one part of winter fishing I don't compromise on.

I wear a life jacket.

Falling out of a boat is always serious.

Falling into extremely cold water while wearing bulky winter clothing adds an entirely different set of problems.

Cold-water immersion can produce an immediate cold-shock response that affects breathing and physical ability before longer-term hypothermia becomes the concern. A properly worn PFD gives you buoyancy when cold, fatigue or shock may reduce your ability to keep yourself afloat.

That's not the situation where I want to discover how long I can tread water.

I also bring spare clothing.

If I end up wet in winter conditions, getting out of those wet clothes and getting somewhere warm becomes the priority.

Winter isn't the time to leave the life jacket sitting somewhere else in the boat because it's uncomfortable over your coat.

Wear it.

Know When It's Just Too Cold

I enjoy being outside.

Sometimes probably a little too much.

But winter fishing isn't supposed to be a competition to determine who can tolerate the most misery.

There comes a point where the weather simply isn't worth fighting.

Sustained temperatures well below freezing, high winds, rain, snow or dangerous conditions can turn a fishing trip into something else entirely.

The fish will still be there another day.

Part of becoming a better outdoorsman is learning when to push yourself a little—and when conditions are telling you to stay home.

The Fish Are Still There

Winter fishing can be frustrating.

The bites can be subtle.

The presentations can be painfully slow.

Your hands get cold.

The wind somehow finds every tiny opening in your clothing.

And there will absolutely be days when you spend several hours freezing in a boat wondering why you thought this sounded like fun.

But then there's that little tick in the line.

You set the hook expecting another crappie.

Five minutes later, you're staring at an 8-pound largemouth that just ate one of the smallest baits you brought with you.

Those are the days you remember.

The lesson I've taken from years of fishing through winter isn't that there's one magical lure, one depth or one presentation that always works.

It's that the fish are still there.

Slow down.

Pay attention.

Be willing to downsize.

Find the bait.

Learn the particular water you're fishing.

Be willing to change what you're doing when the fish give you new information.

Dress for the conditions.

And don't forget that cold water deserves a lot more respect than warm water.

Fishing season isn't over just because it's cold.

Sometimes you just have to work a little harder to remind yourself why you're out there.

Remember, you don't know if you don't go—you just gotta get outside and try.

Georgia DNR Rocky Mountain PFA page